🩺🎓Is med school a cult?

Plus: How to hook adult learners

Author

Kyan Lynch
September 08, 2024 • Estimated Reading Time: 8 minutes

👋Hey, it's Ky, thank you for being a MedEdge member!

I checked and it really is September. I know, I can’t believe it either.

Before we get into the good stuff, can I ask you for a quick favor?

Can you think of other medical educators who might enjoy this newsletter (only the ones you like 😉)?

If someone(s) comes to mind, please forward this to them and tell them to:

Thank you! Now back to our regularly scheduled programming…

As always, this week’s Newsletter is in SOAP note format:

  • Subjective: An expert opinion or provocative idea

  • Objective: A fact, insight, or pro-tip

  • Assessment: Test your MedEd knowledge

  • Plan: Upcoming dates and events

Subjective: Is Med School a Cult?

According to the hosts of the “Sounds Like a Cult” podcast, it sure has some “culty” characteristics, like:

  • Highly structured

  • Elitism & exclusivity

  • Loss of control over life

  • Free/cheap labor expected

  • Exhaustion is a badge of honor

  • Once you’re in, the cost to exit is very high

  • Marrying into it - you go where your partner matches

  • Substantial power imbalances and history of power abuse

  • Class ranking promotes internal competitiveness for authority’s approval

  • Elaborate rituals around milestones (white coat ceremony, Match day, graduation)

What do you think?

Is Medical School a Cult?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.

Objective: How to Hook Adult Learners

What makes adult learners different from young learners?

Go ahead, have a think.

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

How’d you do?

Here are some of the things I came up with:

  • Adults are older (duh!)

  • Adults have experienced things in life and have made it this far

  • Adults have more external pressures and responsibilities taking up mental energy

  • Adults typically learn in higher-stakes situations

  • Adults have more autonomy and can probably get up and leave if they want (usually without raising their hand for a bathroom pass)

  • Adults really hate getting things wrong or looking dumb in front of peers (especially physicians/medical students)

That said, adults and children share many characteristics as learners:

  • Naturally curious

  • Like getting their “hands on” when learning

  • Social and collaborative learning can be enjoyable

In fact, when it comes to acquiring and storing knowledge, adults and kids aren’t that different. But context and attitude set adults apart—and that’s where your approach matters. So how can you engage adult learners in active learning?

There are many ways, but since humans can hold onto 3-5 items in working memory at a time, let’s focus in on 4:

🧱 Use what they already know

Adults bring years of experience to the table. They expect their knowledge and skills to be respected. By intentionally tapping into their past experiences, you not only show that respect but also prime their minds to build on what they already know—or to find ways of reconciling new, conflicting information.

🧁 Make the upside obvious

This involves two key things:

  1. Understanding their day-to-day challenges and experiences.

  2. Tailoring your content so it clearly helps them achieve a goal or solve a problem

(Or, you could always bribe them with baked goods. That works too. 😆)

🤔 Allow them to struggle (a little)

Contrary to popular belief, adults don’t want to be spoon-fed. They’re self-directed and love a challenge. By introducing a bit of friction—also known as desirable difficulty—you can keep them engaged and encourage deeper learning.

🏆 Give them wins

Adults really hate looking dumb and will do almost anything to avoid it. So while it’s important to offer challenges, make sure they’re not constantly facing an uphill battle. Sprinkle in some wins along the way, so they get that sweet, sweet dopamine hit from making a breakthrough.

Resources for deeper dives:

📖Book Recommendation!

I absolutely love both of Julie Dirksen’s books on learning design and she’s offering a 50% off sale with code: BACKTOLEARN. This offer is valid through 9/13.

I’m not an affiliate and I don’t receive any kickbacks for promoting these books; I’m a genuine fan.

Assessment: Pop Quiz!

⏮️Last Week’s Question:

What is the correct definition of interleaving?

✅Studying multiple topics in one session to boost learning and retention

Plan: Upcoming Dates & Events

Want to share an upcoming event? Respond to this email directly with the date, title, and URL for more information.

How was this week's newsletter?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.

P.S - Have you ever thought about sharing your expertise more widely, and even earning extra income doing so? If so, you’ll love the freebies I have for you on my website, kyanlynch.com